|
John H. Graham IV, CAE President & CEO, ASAE |
Associations are pioneers of collaborative problem solving, what we call The Power of A. In that spirit, ASAE created this site to stimulate discussion among association leaders, policymakers & other stakeholders, so that the best and brightest ideas can be shared & help resolve issues of importance. Please join in our conversation. Every voice is welcomed. Every opinion valued. Every solution in sight. Thank you. |
Join the association community's open forum as we work to solve the nation's most critical issues.
According to multiple sources, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) told Senate Finance Committee Chair Max Baucus (D-MT) to stop trying to negotiate with committee Republicans and to begin pushing his health care bill out of committee.
Reid expressed concerns that Baucus’s proposed legislation would not have a public plan but would include language removing the deduction for employer-based health care coverage. Public plan proponents have been increasingly vocal this week, with House Democrats yesterday criticizing White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel over comments suggesting the public plan was not a mandatory part of health care reform.
Reports of the criticism came after yesterday’s weekly Democratic leadership meeting. Roll Call reports that Reid’s message was delivered through an intermediary after the majority leader had consulted with the caucus leaders. The newspaper also reports that Reid’s message told Baucus the lack of a public plan would cost his bill 10-15 Democratic votes, and that losing so many in the caucus was not worth the effort to gain a few Republican votes.
Additionally, concern has been raised in the Democratic caucus over the employer-deduction proposal after polling shows 70% of Americans are opposed to removing the deduction. An idea being discussed is a surtax on families with income above $250,000 as an alternative to pay for the reform legislation, but there is a general uncertainty as to what is going to be used to pay for the Finance Committee’s legislation. Senator Baucus acknowledged as much by saying: “It’s a very complex bill. People are getting skittish all around.”
If you were a member of Congress, how would you propose to pay for health care reform?
Quick Hits
The American Hospital Association, Catholic Health Association, and Federation of American Hospitals will announce with Vice President Joe Biden $155 billion in health care savings over 10 years… Washington Post examines the idea of “rationing” in health care reform… Congressional Budget Office scores the House Tri-Committee health care bill (subscription) at $1.5 trillion over ten years, House leaders expected to announce their revenue raisers today… the HELP Committee finishes debate on the long-term care sections of their health care bill.
In an interview with the Associated Press, Maine Senator Olympia Snowe (R-ME) outlined her support for a public plan with a trigger option as a possible compromise to the stalemate over inclusion of a public plan in comprehensive health care reform.
The trigger option would mean a government-run insurance company would only come into existence if private insurance companies failed to enact specified reforms. Senator Snowe stated her opposition to a public plan that is immediately created, saying: “If you establish a public option at the forefront that goes head-to-head and competes with the private health insurance market … the public option will have significant price advantages”
However, in the interview she expressed a desire to reform the insurance market. “I don’t think we can entirely depend on the private insurance market to deliver. They haven’t delivered thus far, and that’s why we’re in the predicament we’re in today,” she said.
Also this morning, Politico obtained a Senate Health Education Labor and Pension (HELP) Committee document outlining its proposal for a public plan in its legislation. The proposal would be a weaker version of the House version of the public plan, but more government-oriented than the co-op proposal. Details of the “Community Health Insurance Option” can be found here, but highlights include:
- The public plan would be an offering to the bill’s insurance exchange, and would follow the same rules as private insurers except the federal government would set reserve requirements.
- For the first three months, the government (specifically HHS) would pay the plan’s claims. This would be considered a loan to be repaid by the plan.
- The payment rates paid by the public plan would be no more than the local average of private rates, but could be less.
- There is no requirement that a health care provider participate in the plan.
Quick Hits
White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs gives a non-committal answer (subscription) to whether the president is open to taxing employer-provided health care… the Small Business Coalition for Affordable Healthcare releases its first YouTube video… a list of other groups advertising (subscription) over the Congressional recess.
President Obama yesterday addressed the annual meeting of the American Medical Association (AMA) and waded into some of the controversies surrounding health care reform.
Last week, the AMA issued a statement expressing discomfort with the idea of a public insurance plan, and has scheduled a vote this week during the annual meeting to establish a position on the idea. The president tried to woo the membership by addressing the issue head on and reiterating the argument that it was needed to level the playing field with traditional insurance companies.
President Obama also ruled-out the idea of reform including a “single payer system” or all health insurance provided by the government: “There are countries where a single-payer system may be working. But I believe - and I’ve even taken some flak from members of my own party for this belief - that it is important for us to build on our traditions here in the United States. So, when you hear the naysayers claim that I’m trying to bring about government-run health care, know this - they are not telling the truth.”
In addition, the president reiterated his support for legislation with employer and individual mandates as well as calling for a revenue-neutral bill paid for by his charitable tax deduction rate reduction proposal and elimination of waste in the health care system. He also referred to health care costs as a “ticking time-bomb” that needs to be addressed to prevent a long-term budget disaster.
Rep. Tom Price (R-GA), a non-practicing orthopedic surgeon and AMA member, held a pre-speech conference call with reporters to argue against any proposed public plan. “When the government is running something, it subsidizes it to the point private industry can’t compete,” he said on the call.
Did you find President Obama’s speech convincing (especially if you work in a medical profession)?
Quick Hits
Congressional Budget Office releases HELP bill estimates (letter here)… Kaiser Family Foundation Poll finds Americans support health care reforms, but not pay-fors… American Hospital Association CEO (and ASAE member) Richard Umbdenstock speaks out against president’s plan to cut Medicare and Medicaid… Today’s 2:30 PM HELP Committee hearing has been moved to tomorrow (Wednesday) at 10:00 AM.
Senators from both parties and key committees are beginning to voice support for an idea proposed by Senator Kent Conrad (D-ND) earlier this week that is an alternative to a government-run public insurance company (”public plan”).
While complete details have not been released, Conrad’s proposal would allow the creation of a series of state and regional consumer health cooperatives (”co-ops”). The co-ops would be non-profit, non-government insurance options for the self-employed or small businesses regulated by standards from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. These types of arrangements are found in other sectors of the economy, including agriculture. The National Cooperative Business Association and National Rural Electric Cooperative Association provide good examples of how current cooperatives operate.
Since the cooperatives would not be government run and exist currently, the idea has gained support from Republicans such as Finance Committee ranking member Charles Grassley (R-IA): “If it can be presented as an entirely…private-sector operation and incentive and like co-ops that we know, generally in the Midwest, I think it’s got some possibilities.” However, the idea still is under-development; the National Journal is reporting (subscription) that Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) is working with Senator Conrad to make the idea palatable to pro-public plan Democrats.
Associations such as ASAE have been pushing for pooling ideas such as cooperatives (like the Small Business CHOICE Act) as a way to provide savings for small businesses and the self-employed. Can cooperatives (run by associations or not) be a viable alternative to a public plan?
Quick Hits
Baucus staff threatens Democratic health care lobbyists - again (subscription)… Baucus announces a June 23rd mark-up of health care legislation, with a “draft mark” released June 17… Democratic infighting on health care examined by Politico… The American Medical Association comes out against the public plan… President Obama takes health care push to Wisconsin… The Washington Post profiles maybe the most important person in the health care debate.
Join the Conversation
Help us share The Power of A with all Americans. Watch for dialog that sparks an idea, help someone solve a problem or offer up your best business practices. We all hold the key to resolving the nation's most pressing issues. Let's do it together today.
Recent Posts
- Valuable Links for ASAE Fly-In Attendees
- ASAE To Honor Senator Warner and Representative Ehlers at 2010 Fly-In
- Congratulations to the First Round of AAA Award Winners
- Top Five Reasons to Attend American Associations Day
- Look Who’s Coming to American Associations Day 2010
Links for Prospective Participants
Information about the event
- 2010 Schedule of Events
- Fly-in Tip Sheet for attendees
- List of organizations that have participated in the past
- Q&A on Why to Attend the Fly-In
American Associations Day 2009
Links for Registrants
Travel to DC
Planning Your Hill Visits
- Find contact information for your member of Congress
- Fly-In Member 2 Member page
- Register your Hill appointment with ASAE
- Sample meeting request letter
Tags
- AAA Awards
- affordable housing
- AHA
- AHIP
- AMA
- American Associations Day
- Baucus
- Blue Dogs
- CBO
- climate change
- co-ops
- Conrad
- counseling
- economy
- education
- employment
- finance
- finance committee
- Grassley
- guest post
- H1N1
- healthcare
- Health Care
- health care reform
- HELP
- mandate
- Medicare
- net neutrality
- obama
- Pelosi
- public option
- public plan
- Reid
- small business
- small employer subsidy
- Snowe
- Summit Awards
- the power of a
- tourism
- training
- travel
- video
- VOA
- Waxman
- workforce
Recent Comments
- Looking forward to a productive trip in DC!
Tim Seeden
Tim Seeden on ASAE Fly-In Schedule - Updated - [COLOR="Red"][B]Click on the pictures to view in full size[/B][/COLOR]
[URL=http://www.wallpaperhungama.in/details...
upsedsNodeRep on Guest Post: Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs - One more item, this Christmas I am hosting three Europeans. I asked them about the Irish, English and French medical...
Jon Marden on Summary of Merged Senate Health Care Bill - If in the 1960's President Kennedy suggested that we put a man on the moon by propelling a rocket with a large rubber...
Jon Marden on Summary of Merged Senate Health Care Bill - The rejection of the public option by the Senate is very sad. There is a very large demographic of people that are be...
Maguire on Summary of Merged Senate Health Care Bill
#PWRA Twitter 
- got something cool to tell about your association and its impact - use #pwra hashtag
-assn_volunteer, about 15 hours ago - Use #pwra to tweet about American Associations Day 2010
-roberthayjr, about 2 days ago
(Service)A
School Nutrition Association
Program: Vote for School Lunch 2008 - Presidential Edition
Description: The culmination of SNA’s most popular campaign ever - “Vote for School Lunch 2008 - Presidential Edition” - was very successful at teaching kids about the benefits of school lunch and increasing school lunch participation during a tough economic time for most families. SNA members applauded this popular program as a fun way to empower kids to choose school lunch.
(Recovery)A
Seldom has working together been more important to our success. We're depending on teamwork to resolve our nation's most pressing issues such as healthcare, education, employment and housing. Trade & professional groups and not-for-profits in every industry and profession have perfected the art of collaboration - a valuable skill when all of the country's strength is needed to rebuild the economy. That's Recovery...to the Power of A.




Tags: AHA, Baucus, CBO, Emanuel, employer-provided coverage, healthcare, public plan, Reid